Inaccurate: No nickel or “DNA adducts” are present in vaccines. Vaccine ingredients are safe. Buttar inaccurately claims that the current rate of autism is 1 in 29 and falsely attributes this rate to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). The CDC has reported it to be 1 in 54.
FULL CLAIM: “Autism is nothing more than mercury toxicity“; vaccine ingredients are toxic
These claims were made by doctor of osteopathy Rashid Buttar on 30 April 2020, during a video interview. Excerpts of the video, which have been archived here and here, have been shared across social media platforms such as Facebook many times, and the claims have been made on many other occasions by prominent individuals, such as Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and former U.S. congressman Dan Burton. Buttar rehashes the discredited yet persistent claim that vaccines cause autism, and attributes this to mercury toxicity from thimerosal.
Numerous large-scale studies have already shown that there is no association between vaccines and autism[1-21]. Buttar misleadingly conflates the element mercury with the compound thimerosal. While it is true that elemental mercury is highly toxic, and that thimerosal contains this element, thimerosal has very different chemical properties. One example that illustrates the difference between elements and compounds is sodium chloride, better known as table salt. Table salt is generally harmless, whereas elemental sodium reacts violently upon contact with water and elemental chlorine was used as a chemical weapon during World War I.
Thimerosal is used in vaccines as a preservative and antibacterial. It is metabolized to nontoxic ethylmercury, which is degraded and eliminated by the body quickly. Ethylmercury is quite different from methylmercury, which is an environmental toxin that can accumulate in the body at levels sufficient to cause toxicity. According to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, “Nearly all methylmercury exposures in the U.S. occur through eating fish and shellfish that contain higher levels of methylmercury.” A far less common source is industrial methylmercury pollution, notably in Minamata Bay, Japan, more than 50 years ago. Despite the fact that thimerosal is completely unrelated to methylmercury, persistent public concern over mercury toxicity led to the removal of thimerosal from pediatric vaccines in the United States in 2001. It is no longer present in most vaccines, with the exception of certain multi-dose influenza vaccines, which are likewise not toxic or linked to autism. According to the Vaccine Education Center at the Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia:
“Although it is clear that large quantities of mercury can damage the nervous system, there is no evidence that the small quantities contained in water, infant formula, and breast milk do. An infant who is exclusively breastfed will ingest more than twice the quantity of mercury that was ever contained in vaccines and 15 times the quantity of mercury contained in the influenza vaccine.”
Buttar claims that vaccines labeled thimerosal-free still contain thimerosal but provides no evidence to support his statement. He also makes several claims about the toxicity of other vaccine ingredients, namely formaldehyde, nickel, aluminum, and “DNA adducts”, again without any scientific evidence. It is true that formaldehyde can be toxic and that it is used in vaccine production. However, the amount of formaldehyde present in vaccines is too low to cause toxicity. The Vaccine Education Center at the Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia states:
“Formaldehyde is essential in human metabolism and is required for the synthesis of DNA and amino acids (the building blocks of protein). Therefore, all humans have detectable quantities of natural formaldehyde in their circulation (about 2.5 ug of formaldehyde per ml of blood). Assuming an average weight of a 2-month-old of 5 kg and an average blood volume of 85 ml per kg, the total quantity of formaldehyde found in an infant’s circulation would be about 1.1 mg, a value about 1,500 times more than the amount an infant would be exposed to in any individual vaccine.”
Nickel is not used in vaccine formulations and Buttar provides no evidence to the contrary.
Aluminium is not used in its elemental form in vaccines, but in the form of aluminium salts which act as adjuvants. Adjuvants are used to heighten the immune response upon vaccination and enhance protection during subsequent natural infection. While it is possible for them to trigger side effects if used in excessive amounts, the levels in vaccines are low and safe.
The claim that vaccines contain DNA adducts, which are short segments of DNA to which a carcinogenic chemical has become bound, is similar to other claims which have been reviewed by Health Feedback and found to be inaccurate and unsupported.
Buttar has been reprimanded twice by the North Carolina Board of Medical Examiners, once in 2010 and again in 2019, for unethical behavior and was warned by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration for selling medications which had not been adequately tested according to federal regulations.
He has also promoted chelation therapy as a treatment for conditions ranging from cancer to autism, despite the lack of evidence for its efficacy. Chelation therapy uses certain compounds, such as ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid or EDTA for short, that bind to metals and promote the removal of metals from the body. While chelation therapy is highly effective for treating heavy metal poisoning, its effectiveness has not been demonstrated for the treatment of cancer or autism. A 2015 Cochrane Review concluded that there is “no high‐quality evidence to suggest that chelation is an effective treatment for improving [autism spectrum disorder] ASD symptoms.” The authors of the review even added that “Cochrane reviews typically avoid making recommendations for practice; however, given that harm resulting from the use of chelation therapy has been reported, and that no proven benefits have been found, it seems reasonable to conclude that use of chelation for the treatment of individuals with ASD symptoms should not be recommended.”
Autism spectrum disorder (ASD) is generally understood to arise from a combination of genetics and environment, and twin studies have indicated a strong heritable component to ASD, with heritability estimates ranging from about 30 to 90%[23-26]. Many genes have been associated with ASD risk, several of which are involved in brain development. However, the contribution of each gene towards this risk is unclear and still a matter of intense study. Buttar’s claim that autism is linked to “a genetic predisposition for the inability to excrete mercury” is unsupported.
Buttar uses health authorities’ acknowledgement of an association between genes and ASD to misleadingly suggest that the authorities attribute recent increases in ASD diagnoses to a “genetic epidemic”. This is an example of a strawman fallacy: while rates of ASD diagnosis have indeed increased, health authorities and experts largely attribute the increase to changes in ASD diagnostic criteria and greater awareness of the condition, which have enabled physicians to identify more cases, as this article explains.
Buttar’s claim that the current rate of autism is 1 in 29, which he falsely attributes to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), is inaccurate. The CDC has reported it to be 1 in 54.
Vaccines do not cause cancer, as Health Feedback concluded in a previous review. A previous Insight article also explained that vaccines do not cause autism and another review covered an incorrect claim regarding vaccine ingredient safety.
Mark Pepys, Emeritus Professor, Division of Medicine, University College London:
[This comment was first published on Metafact.]
There is absolutely no single shred of evidence that vaccination, of any type, causes autism. There is also absolutely no shred of scientific evidence about either vaccination or autism suggesting any possible mechanism that could be responsible for such an association.
Neal Halsey, Professor Emeritus, Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health:
[This comment comes from the evaluation of a related claim.]
Some vaccines do contain very small (trace) amounts of formaldehyde, which is a natural product produced by all mammalian cells. The trace amounts in some vaccines are residuals from the manufacturing process. In high concentrations, formaldehyde is toxic to cells and organisms. It is used to kill some of the organisms that are used to make vaccines and then purification removes all but a trace of the formaldehyde. The trace amounts that are left as a residual in vaccines are considered to have no additive effect to the naturally produced formaldehyde in our bodies.
Thimerosal is a mercury-containing preservative that is only used in some of the many different influenza vaccines that are available today. In the late 1990s and early 2000s, thimerosal was removed as a preservative from all pediatric vaccines with the exception of some influenza vaccines. Thimerosal-free influenza vaccines are available for children and pregnant women upon request in virtually all settings where these vaccines are given.
All of us are exposed to substances that are potentially toxic when we are exposed to high concentrations for long periods of time. None of the substances in vaccines are considered to be “toxic” in the concentrations that are in vaccines.
James D. Cherry, Professor (Pediatrics), David Geffen School of Medicine, University of California Los Angeles:
[This comment comes from the evaluation of a related claim.]
There is aluminum salt present in killed vaccines, such as the present DTaP and Tdap vaccines, but it’s a very good adjuvant and it’s been in killed vaccines from the very beginning. The amount and the actual aluminum salt may vary with vaccines. The key thing is that too much aluminum would give you abscesses at the site of vaccination, but no present killed vaccine has excessive amounts. In live vaccines there’s no aluminum at all.
Ethylmercury, which is from thimerosal, is very safe, and it degrades so that there’s no problem whatsoever. The problem is that regular mercury is very toxic. Methylmercury, which contaminates fish for example, is also toxic. But ethylmercury acts as a preservative and also as an antibacterial, so it prevents vaccines from being contaminated with bad bacteria. The confusion of roles [between ethylmercury and methylmercury]—and this happened with people who should have known better—created the push to get mercury out of vaccines. There was thimerosal in the DTP vaccine and also later when the hepatitis B vaccine came along, which we gave right at birth. Although the amount of mercury appeared to exceed the EPA level, that level is for methylmercury, not ethylmercury. Nevertheless, that prompted the move to take mercury out of vaccines, and so our present killed vaccines have no mercury in any of them, with the possible exception of multi-dose vials of some influenza vaccines.
The whole idea was wrong from the beginning. Ethylmercury is incredibly safe and we know that because back before we had antibiotics, it was given in an attempt to treat serious infections, in large doses—a thousand times bigger than what’s in any vaccine. And of course in any live vaccine, there’s no mercury whatsoever.
Health Feedback previously reviewed similar false claims regarding a causal association between vaccines and autism, here and here. This Insight article explains how this link has been discredited.
- 1 – Madsen et al. (2002) A Population-Based Study of Measles, Mumps, and Rubella Vaccination and Autism. New England Journal of Medicine.
- 2 – Institute of Medicine. (2013). Adverse Effects of Vaccines: Evidence and Causality. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.17226/13164
- 3 – Institute of Medicine. (2004). Immunization Safety Review: Vaccines and Autism. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.17226/10997
- 4 – Institute of Medicine. (2013). Childhood Immunization Schedule and Safety: Stakeholder Concerns, Scientific Evidence, and Future Studies. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.17226/13563
- 5 – Fombonne et al. (2006). Pervasive developmental disorders in Montreal, Quebec, Canada: prevalence and links with immunizations. Pediatrics.
- 6 – Taylor et al. (2014). Vaccines are not associated with autism: an evidence-based meta-analysis of case-control and cohort studies. Vaccine.
- 7 – Ball et al. (2001) An assessment of thimerosal use in childhood vaccines. Pediatrics.
- 8 – Hviid et al. (2003) Association Between Thimerosal-Containing Vaccine and Autism. JAMA.
- 9 – Madsen et al. (2003) Thimerosal and the occurrence of autism: negative ecological evidence from Danish population-based data. Pediatrics.
- 10 – Stehr-Green et al. (2003) Autism and thimerosal-containing vaccines: lack of consistent evidence for an association. American Journal of Preventive Medicine.
- 11 – Verstraeten et al. (2003) Safety of thimerosal-containing vaccines: a two-phased study of computerized health maintenance organization databases. Pediatrics.
- 12 – Andrews et al. (2004). Thimerosal exposure in infants and developmental disorders: a retrospective cohort study in the United Kingdom does not support a causal association. Pediatrics.
- 13 – Thompson et al. (2007) Early Thimerosal Exposure and Neuropsychological Outcomes at 7 to 10 Years. New England Journal of Medicine.
- 14 – McMahon et al. (2008) Inactivated influenza vaccine (IIV) in children <2 years of age: examination of selected adverse events reported to the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS) after thimerosal-free or thimerosal-containing vaccine. Vaccine.
- 15 – Schechter and Grether. (2008) Continuing increases in autism reported to California’s developmental services system: mercury in retrograde. Archives of General Psychiatry.
- 16 – DeStefano F. (2009) Thimerosal-containing vaccines: evidence versus public apprehension. Expert Opinion on Drug Safety.
- 17 – Tozzi et al. (2009) Neuropsychological performance 10 years after immunization in infancy with thimerosal-containing vaccines. Pediatrics.
- 18 – Price et al. (2010) Prenatal and Infant Exposure to Thimerosal From Vaccines and Immunoglobulins and Risk of Autism. Pediatrics.
- 19 – Barile et al. (2012) Thimerosal exposure in early life and neuropsychological outcomes 7-10 years later. Journal of Pediatric Psychology.
- 20 – DeStefano et al. (2013). Increasing Exposure to Antibody-Stimulating Proteins and Polysaccharides in Vaccines Is Not Associated with Risk of Autism. Journal of Pediatrics.
- 21 – Uno et al. (2012). The combined measles, mumps, and rubella vaccines and the total number of vaccines are not associated with development of autism spectrum disorder: the first case-control study in Asia. Vaccine.
- 22 – James et al. (2015) Chelation for autism spectrum disorder (ASD). Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews.
- 23 – Sandin et al. (2017) The Heritability of Autism Spectrum Disorder. JAMA.
- 24 – Hallmayer et al. (2011) Genetic heritability and shared environmental factors among twin pairs with autism. Archives of General Psychiatry.
- 25 – Colvert et al. (2015) Heritability of Autism Spectrum Disorder in a UK Population-Based Twin Sample. JAMA Psychiatry.
- 26 – Tick et al. (2016) Heritability of autism spectrum disorders: a meta-analysis of twin studies. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry.
- 27 – Chahrour et al. (2016) Current Perspectives in Autism Spectrum Disorder: From Genes to Therapy. Journal of Neuroscience.